Cake & Pie Menu

6″ Round (feeds 5-6)
8″ Round (feeds 8-10)
10″ Round (feeds up to 20)
6″ Round (feeds 5-6)
8″ Round (feeds 8-10)
10″ Round (feeds up to 20)

Cake Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Lemon, Marble, Funfetti, White

Frostings: Vanilla, Chocolate, Raspberry, Mocha, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Chocolate Ganache Drip, Swiss Meringue Buttercream, Seasonal Fruit and Whipped Cream

Special Fillings: Chocolate Mousse, Fruit Compote (Raspberry, Strawberry, Blueberry), Lemon Curd, Tiramisu Inspired, Seasonal Fruit and Whipped Cream

Popular Favorites

  • Carrot Cake

    Cake made with shredded carrots, crushed pineapple, and coconut. (no nuts). Cream Cheese frosting. Sided with toasted coconut

  • Coconut

    Cake made with chopped coconute and coconut milk. Vanilla / Cream Cheese frosting. Sided with shredded coconut.

  • Red Velvet

    Cake made natural without food coloring (cocoa powder and beet powder). The color is a deeper red than artificial colored red velvet. Cream Cheese frosting.

Specialty Cakes

Pie Flavors

Available in 9-inch.

Sweet Pies

Also available Gluten-Sensitive, add $4. Please specify when ordering! (We are not a gluten nor nut free establishment for those with allergies)
  • Fruit or Pumpkin $21
  • Banana, Chocolate or Coconut Cream $24
  • Key Lime or Lemon Meringue $24

Individual "Sweetie Pies"

  • Bakers Choice Daily, or special order Price Varies

Savory Pies

  • Pork Pie $25
  • Chicken Pot Pie $25
  • Quiche $21

Seasonal Pies

  • Strawberry Rhubarb $21
  • Peach $24
  • Pumpkin Pie $21
  • Pecan Pie $24

Sweetie Pies

4" Regular. Baker’s choice daily in the café or by special order.

Dessert Platters

Have a special occasion and need an assortment of desserts?

Cookies and Brownies

Platters can include, but not limited to: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Hermits, Peanut Butter Cookie, Brownies and Blondies with Various Toppings.
  • Small (36 pieces) $46
  • Large (72 pieces) $82

Finger Pastries

Platters can include, but not limited: Lemon Squares, Amaretto Fudge Brownies, Fruit Topped Cheesecakes, Pecan Diamonds, Butter Brickle Triangles, and Carrot Cupcakes
  • Small (30 pieces) $46
  • Large (60 pieces) $82

MiniWhoopie Pies

Awarded “Best Whoopie Pies in New England”, these bite-sized versions are always a popular treat! Popular flavors are: Traditional, Peanut Butter, Mint, Cookies and Cream or Raspberry
We are not a gluten or nut free establishment. We can produce many of our cakes and pies without gluten, dairy, or with vegan ingredients for additional charge

Just Like Mom's Pastries

is now