Pie & Cakes Menu


6" Round (feeds 5-6) 8" Round (feeds 8-10) 10" Round (feeds up to 20) 12" Round (feeds up to 30) 14" Round (feeds up to 40)
  • Baileys $26/36

    Vanilla cake, Baileys liquor, Baileys buttercream

  • Black Forest $26/36

    Chocolate cake, Kirsch, cherry filling, and vanilla buttercream.

  • Boston Cream $25/35

    Vanilla cake, homemade custard, vanilla buttercream and chocolate glaze.

  • Carrot Cake $25/35

    Carrot cake made with crushed pineapple and coconut, cream cheese frosting, sided with toasted coconut.

  • Chocolate Mousse $25/35

    Chocolate cake, chocolate mousse, chocolate buttercream, and chocolate glaze.

  • Coconut $25/35

    Coconut cake layer cake with vanilla buttercream frosting sided with toasted coconut.

  • Chocolate Raspberry Truffle $26/36

    Chocolate cake, raspberry liquor, raspberry buttercream, chocolate mousse and chocolate buttercream

  • German Chocolate $25/35

    Light chocolate cake, filled with pecan coconut caramel, chocolate buttercream.

  • Lemon Olive Oil $23/31

    Italian Olive Oil Cake, lemon curd, lemon cream cheese frosting.

  • Lemon Raspberry Torte $24/32

    Vanilla cake, lemon glaze, raspberry buttercream, vanilla buttercream and topped with raspberry jam.

  • Maple Walnut $25/35

    Maple walnut cake, maple buttercream and topped with walnuts.

  • Mudslide $26/36

    Chocolate Cake, Kahula liquor, Bailey’s buttercream

  • Red Velvet $25/33

    Red velvet cake made natural without food coloring, cream cheese frosting.

  • Toasted Almond $26/36

    Vanilla cake, Amaretto liquor, Kahlua buttercream and sided with toasted almonds.

  • 5-Layer Spice (seasonal) $24/32

    Cake flavored with cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, allspice with cream cheese frosting.

Available in 5-inch and 6-inch.
  • Chocolate Ganache $19/24

    Chocolate buttermilk cake, milk chocolate buttercream layer with dark Belgium Chocolate ganache poured on top.

  • Coconut $19/24

    Coconut Cake layer cake with vanilla buttercream frosting sided with toasted coconut

We are not a gluten and nut free establishment for those who are allergic to these products, we try our best to please our customers.

Pie Flavors

Available in 9-inch.

Sweet Pies

Also available Gluten-Sensitive, add $4. Please specify when ordering! (We are not a gluten nor nut free establishment for those with allergies)
  • Fruit or Pumpkin $21
  • Banana, Chocolate or Coconut Cream $22
  • Shoofly $21
  • Chocolate Chess $21
  • Key Lime or Lemon Meringue $21

Individual "Sweetie Pies"

  • Bakers Choice Daily, or special order Price Varies

Savory Pies

  • Pork Pie $24
  • Chicken Pot Pie $23
  • Quiche $21

Seasonal Pies

  • Strawberry Rhubarb $21
  • Peach $24
  • Pumpkin Pie $21
  • Pecan Pie $24

Sweetie Pies

4" Regular. Baker’s choice daily in the café or by special order.

Dessert Platters

Have a special occasion and need an assortment of desserts?

Cookies and Brownies

Platters can include, but not limited to: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Hermits, Peanut Butter Cookie, Brownies and Blondies with Various Toppings.
  • Small (36 pieces) $46
  • Large (72 pieces) $82

Finger Pastries

Platters can include, but not limited: Lemon Squares, Amaretto Fudge Brownies, Fruit Topped Cheesecakes, Pecan Diamonds, Butter Brickle Triangles, and Carrot Cupcakes
  • Small (30 pieces) $46
  • Large (60 pieces) $82

MiniWhoopie Pies

Awarded “Best Whoopie Pies in New England”, these bite-sized versions are always a popular treat! Popular flavors are: Traditional, Peanut Butter, Mint, Raspberry, and Coconut.
  • Per Whoopie Pie $1.50

Just Like Mom's Pastries

is now